Hi Joel,

I hope you are well today and thanks for asking!

I tested Social Sharing Toolkit and Rating Manager plugin on a fresh install and it works. See screenshot – http://i.imgur.com/eFoaI5B.png . In order to fix this issue for you, I need to take a closer look at your site and Social Sharing Toolkit settings.

Could you please share your DEV site credentials with me for a while? You can send me an email to dominykas@elementous.com